I found these 10 gold ear-rings on the street officer

At about 9:30pm last night (Sunday 7 December 2014), Police officers attached to the Geraldton Burglary Suppression Team were conducting patrols of Mount Tarcoola.

Police say they received a report of a burglary in Mt Tarcoola, and they then found a 34 year old man on Shepheard Close. 

It will be alleged that the male person had in his possession

  • beanie

  • gloves

  • screw driver

  • metal jemmy bar

  • similar house breaking implements

The man was also in possession of ten gold earrings that he stated he had found whilst walking the street.

The man, who is from Moora,  has been charged with "Carry or Possess Weapon (other than Controlled or Prohibited) with Intent to Injure or Disable" and "Stealing".

Serious Vehicle Crash Update

Geraldton Police have issued an update following a serious vehicle crash on Thursday December 4 2014. 

Police say:

  • A 34 year old Wandina man has been arrested. 
  • It is alleged the man was travelling south along NWCH. 
  • The driver lost control of the vehicle and it collided with a tree.
  • Four boys aged 4, 6, 7, 8 were passengers and were injured. 
  • The 7 year old received serious injuries. 
  • All of the children were taken to Princess Margaret Hospital by the Royal Flying Doctors. 

The man has been charged with the following:

  • Driving Under the Influence,
  • Three counts of Dangerous Driving Causing Grievous Bodily Harm 
  • One count of Dangerous Driving Causing Bodily Harm

Burglary arrest

On the 19th of November 2014 a burglary was committed at a property situated on African Reef Boulevard, Greenough. At that time a large quantity of property was stolen, inclusive of three (3) four (4) wheeled motorcycles.

Inquiry into this offence by the Geraldton Burglary Suppression Team officers led the identification and arrest of a 26 year old male offender person from Rangeway on 2nd December 2014, and the recovery of some of the stolen property.

As a result the male was charged with the below offences, and will appear in Geraldton Magistrates Court on 18 December 2014.

  1. Burglary with intent to commit offence (Place),
  2. Stealing,
  3. Steal Motor Vehicle.

Witnesses wanted after hammer thrown at car

Sent in to Everything Geraldton:

"Looking for witnesses to a incident this morning; hammer thrown at car at intersection of Eastward Rd and North West Coastal Hwy Lights at 6.50 this morning."

Please contact Geraldton Police if you saw or know anything.  

9923 4555

Regarding the Cemetery vandalism: An ongoing concern

The following has been supplied by the Geraldton Cemetery Board in response to a recent incident reported by some Everything Geraldton readers. (Click here to read original post.)


With reference to the post about trashed graves at Geraldton Cemetery, (Everything Geraldton, Nov 25) the desecration of graves and wanton vandalism is an ongoing issue for the Geraldton Cemetery Board and staff.

Geraldton Cemetery Board Chairman, Max Correy, said the vandalism is not confined to gravesites.

“Apart from the damage and destruction to people’s loved ones’ graves and monuments, the perpetrators also damage and pull out recently planted trees, shrubs and gardens and rip out reticulation systems,” he said.

“Our ground staff – of which there are only two to care for the grounds, operate the cremator and prepare graves – are tired and despairing of arriving at work to discover the vandalism and find reticulation ripped out.

“All of this destruction creates an extra workload for them to replant and re-establish reticulation directing financial resources and their time away from important projects,” said Mr Correy.

The use of the cemetery grounds as a thoroughfare between Eastward Road, Alexander Street and Abraham Street is causing the Cemetery Board great concern and anguish. The Board empathises with the families whose grave sites are being vandalised.

“In spite of the police and Yamatji Patrol’s efforts to eliminate the damage, the vandalism continues unabated,” Mr Correy said.

The only real solution is to erect a security fence but as the cemetery is a self-funded public utility, not a City of Greater Geraldton asset as is commonly believed, the ability to fund such a solution is beyond the Board’s capacity.

“The Board would be interested in any alternative solutions, perhaps we could hold a public appeal to help fund a security fence, as the cemetery’s only form of income is through cremations and burials, and other funding that the Board is able to secure from time to time,” he said.

 

Travellers' insulin stolen

Police say that insulin dependant tourists travelling around Australia have had their medication stolen from Sunset Beach Caravan Park. 

It is believed the theft occurred between 9pm Friday and 12pm Saturday.  

The unknown offenders entered the communal kitchen area of the Sunset Beach Caravan Park and stole 3 months’ worth of liquid insulin from the fridge.

The medication was stored in a square shaped carry bag, made specifically for storing items in the fridge. The bag has a blue identification tag on the top with "Heinz and Syville" written on it.

If anyone has any information regarding this theft, please contact crimestoppers on 1800 333 000

Balga man smashes Geraldton McDonalds window just to get a lift from Cops

In what can only be described as an unbelievable display of selfishness, a man has smashed a window at a Geraldton Maccas in order to get a lift home, say Police.

On Tuesday 25 November 2014 at about 12.30am the man attended Geraldton Police Station seeking a lift home.

A taxi was ordered for him to be collected from the police station.

It's unclear why the man chose not to wait for the taxi, but he left the station prior to the arrival of the taxi, heading to McDonalds Restaurant, Durlacher Street in Geraldton.

Police say the man was sitting out the front of McDonalds drinking from a bottle of Tawny Port that was in his possession. The man used the bottle to strike a lower glass panel causing the glass to break.

Police attended and arrested the man.

Shockingly, Police say the man actually told them he smashed the window in order to get a lift home. 

The 45 year old man from Balga was charged with criminal damage and street drinking. He will appear before Geraldton Magistrates Court on 18 December 2014. 

Police seize knives in routine vehicle stop

Geraldton police posted this image on Twitter this morning of knives seized after a routine vehicle stop.

"Geraldton Police sieze more weapons from a routine vehicle stop."

More homes reportedly targeted in Tarcoola Beach last night

We have received reports of more attempted break ins in Tarcoola Beach last night. 

Goldie Walster‎ posted "We had someone try to break into the neighbours house last night in tarcoola beach! Luckily he was seen and jumped off the balcony and did a runner! Keep your windows and doors locked in the area!"

This occurred in Nigel Crescent.

Karlee posted in the Geraldton Neighbourhood Watch group: Last night the neighbours house across the street got broken into, in Tarcoola Beach. There were about 4 of them, all adults. We have Cameras up and managed to see them, but not clear enough to see faces or anything, snooping in their cars trying to find something. They didn't manage to steal anything as they got caught snooping around and bolted down the road. But it's still scary. Why is it getting so out of control, I'm now finding it hard to feel safe anywhere..

Click here to view video. 


This follows reports of two more stolen vehicles from Mt Tarcoola on Monday night, where one of the vehicles was rolled and the other torched. 


One Strathalbyn resident, Collette Jacobs has expressed her frustration with what she believes is the failure of the courts to dish out punishments that would deter bad behaviour, calling for her area to become gated.

"As a resident of Strathalbyn, I am angry and saddened by the recent information regarding the reality of all the Burglaries in Strath and Gero in general. The Police have the 'Burg Squad' up from Perth, with full-on NCIS-like capabilities, dogs etc and yet our own Shire of "Greater" Geraldton are refusing to aid them! When handed a person with proven, hard evidence of several (30-40) Burgs the Magistrate hands down the only sentence they can- 10 hours of community service. COMMUNITY F*&#ING SERVICE !?! So unless we get a Politician with half a brain (good luck with that one....) we are screwed and for those who think moving will help- don't waste your time, as it is everywhere! Everywhere, that is where the parents ignore, pander to bad behaviour and in some cases encourage their kids to steal! I am serious folks, lets get "GATED"!"

If you see anything you'd like to share with the Geraldton community, you can post it straight into the Everything Geraldton smartphone app. Over 11,000 people have downloaded the app, and it's used by thousands of locals every day, It's a great way to stay in touch with what's happening near you.

It’s available on iPhone and Android. 

iPhone: http://evth.in/GeraldtoniPhoneApp

Android: http://evth.in/GeraldtonAndroidApp 

Graves trashed

A concerned community member sent these images in to Everything Geraldton. 

They said:

"My brother discovered these smashed grave while he walked through the cemetery, amongst them were our father's grave, aunty's and our grandmother who is buried with our other aunty... not only our family's graves were smashed also a whole lot more... it is a shame that any person can be so heartless to destroy the only sentimental place we come to gather to mourn our losses... there were beautiful tombstones smashed ... "

Another resident also contacted us recently:

"Sitting here dismayed about my day! My mum went out to the cemetery today to visit my deceased brother and to her horror found his resting place and another's trashed! Lights were destroyed, bottles smashed, a small cross on his cross broken! What kind of a person is so heartless to trash a resting place?! My family is hurt and so angry at this act! This is the 3rd time this has happened since we layed him to rest nearly 2 years ago!
"We are struggling to pay for his head stone and with this happening were wondering if spending money on a toom stone just to be vandalised is actually worth it! I want the person who did this (if they're reading this now) to know that their actions have devastated my family! And that it's disgusting to see a great man -my brother's RESTING place in such condition!
"So to the person who did this to my brothers gave, I say: "how black is your heart?! How would you like this done to someone you love? You put your loved one to rest and you expect them to get that respect and dignity that they deserve! I'm angry that you've done this and I'm hurt that it means nothing to you to trash the cemetery! Shame on you!"

Full transcript and video of Melissa Price's parliament address on Psychoactive Substances

Memo for Ms Price

This proof report is issued by direction of the Speaker.

Ms PRICE (Durack) (13:25): I am pleased to rise to speak on this bill, the Crimes Legislation Amendment (Psychoactive Substances and Other Measures) Bill 2014, and about an issue which is, sadly, very important within my large electorate of Durack and in all communities throughout Australia. This bill amends a series of acts including the Criminal Code Act 1995, the Customs Act 1901 and the Surveillance Devices Act 2004. The bill contains a range of measures to improve Commonwealth criminal justice arrangements, including the following three: banning the importation of substances that have a psychoactive effect but are not otherwise regulated or banned; ensuring that Australian Customs and Border Protection Service officers have appropriate powers to stop these substances at the borders; and validating access by the Australian Federal Police to certain investigative powers in designated state airports.

While the bill comprises six schedules, I want to focus today on schedule 1, which will amend the Criminal Code Act and the Customs Act to strengthen the Commonwealth's ability to respond to new and emerging illicit drugs, known as new psychoactive substances. These so-called synthetic drugs are designed to mimic the effect of illicit drugs, but their chemical compositions are not captured by existing controls on these drugs. Effectively, what we are talking about is the new ice. There is evidence that manufacturers design the chemical structures of new psychoactive substances to avoid current controls and prohibitions. The amendments in schedule 1 will fill the regulatory gap. They will ensure that new psychoactive substances cannot be imported while the government assesses their harm and considers the appropriate controls to place on them. The measure takes a precautionary approach to dealing with psychoactive substances. It is intended not to replace but to work in parallel with the existing arrangements which regulate the importation of both illicit drugs and substances with a legitimate use into Australia.

The largest urban centre in my electorate is Geraldton, with a population edging on 40,000 people. Too many of its residents suffer from alcohol misuse or from the harm arising from illicit drug use and its associated impacts, including harm to mental health and crime. I am advised by some working in the drug and alcohol services industry that the culture around alcohol in Geraldton is ridiculous. They cited an anecdote about a bouncer, recently seen sprawled on his back across the bar and being fed alcohol through a hose. There are pockets of amphetamine use—drugs such as speed or ice—together with a proportion of new psychoactive substances. These are causing serious issues because they simply cannot be tested at present.

Let us talk about the notions of responsibility and acceptance. Personal harm associated with the use of drugs is considered to be high. In comparison, related crimes such as road accidents and domestic violence are more strongly linked to alcohol abuse. In general, there is an acceptance by those who are extreme drinkers or amphetamine users of substance use and abuse and its impacts—and the acceptance of this use and abuse and its impacts plays an essential role in these people's ongoing substance abuse. But there is an expectation that the police, drug and alcohol agencies will somehow fix the problem, rather than users taking personal responsibility for their own actions and behaviours.

We know that one woman each week in Australia dies from domestic violence. This is clearly not acceptable. I would like to pause for a moment to recognise White Ribbon Day, which is tomorrow 25 November. White Ribbon Day is the international day for the elimination of violence against women and a day when we must stand against domestic violence. This is a community-wide issue in my electorate of Durack. Violence against women and children and much of this harm is fuelled by drug and alcohol abuse.

The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Order! In accordance with standing order 43, the time for members’ statements has concluded. The debate may be resumed at a later hour and the member will have leave to continue her remarks when the debate is resumed.

Ms PRICE (Durack) (15:48): I applaud the Australian and New Zealand police commissioners who this morning came together here at Parliament House to stand against violence towards women and children. I was particularly pleased to see my Western Australian commissioner, Karl O'Callaghan, who joined with this group. This is a very powerful union which sends a strong message that our police leaders take claims of domestic violence seriously and puts perpetrators of domestic violence on notice that Australia does not tolerate domestic violence towards women and children, that perpetrators will be 'punished with the full severity of the law'—to quote the Prime Minister from this morning's event—and that domestic violence victims will be protected.

In Geraldton, amphetamines and other synthetic drugs are prevalent amongst the general population as well as the Aboriginal population. We all see this in our towns, cities, rural communities and remote communities and also within our workplaces, families, friendship groups and neighbourhoods. I recently hosted a community crime forum in Geraldton where my co-host for the day, the Minister for Justice, the Hon. Michael Keenan, was urgently called back to Canberra as soon as he disembarked his flight in Geraldton. The forum, held on 18 September, went some way towards further fleshing out the drug related crime incidence and the causes and strategies in place to counter these in Geraldton. During the forum, we sought the community's views on what practical and tangible actions might be taken to help address the crime and antisocial behaviour which frequently stems from drug and/or alcohol abuse. I acknowledge the City of Greater Geraldton, the Geraldton police and regional Western Australia commander Murray Smallpage for their support of and participation in the forum and the excellent work they are doing in Geraldton and its surrounds to help combat the supply of drugs into the region and to help combat antisocial behaviour, crime, violence and personal harm arising from drug and alcohol abuse.

It is worth recording some key sentiments that emerged from the crime forum discussions amongst the 50-odd participants. One was that illicit drug use feeds crime, including burglary, house break-ins and muggings, and that the regrettable loss of funding for programs such as the youth bus and Midnight Basketball will have adverse impacts. People are terribly concerned about this because they fear an increase in drug taking, antisocial behavior and crime.

Another observation was that leadership within the Geraldton community, both Indigenous and non-Indigenous, is strong and that joint endeavours to address drugs, crime and associated impacts of harm and violence are characterised by collaboration and planning amongst stakeholders, both government and not-for-profit groups. There is a strong sense that there is capacity in Geraldton to address the problem; however, a long-term view, with bipartisan support and ongoing funding for programs, is an essential element.

Food, clothing, shelter, education and personal safety were considered causal factors for alcohol and drug abuse and resultant antisocial behaviour, harm and violence. Another observation was that drug and alcohol misuse and abuse are symptoms of greater problems and not the cause of people's problems. There was discussion of parental responsibility. Somehow, we must get parents to exercise responsibility. Money for programs can only achieve so much and is not the complete answer. It is about changing children's lives with their parents; it is not just about taking kids of the streets—although that is a jolly good start.

The discussion at the Geraldton community crime forum inevitably led to discussions that alcohol and illicit drugs are root causes of crime and antisocial behaviour, including domestic violence, underpinned by a range of social issues with which we here are all too familiar.

A number of my constituents in Geraldton are passionate crusaders for drug reform. In particular, they campaign for a reduction in drug usage rather than for a reduction in harm caused by illicit drugs, which, they allege, simply fuels the gateway of the ongoing criminality of illicit drug dealing, manufacture and usage. The Crimes Legislation Amendment (Psychoactive Substances and Other Measures) Bill 2014 will ensure that new psychoactive substances cannot be imported while the government assesses the harm they cause and considers the appropriate controls to place on them—thereby limiting supply and usage.

I am using the opportunity today to commend the work and the initiative being undertaken by the Midwest Gascoyne Human Services Regional Managers Group. This group comprises around 20 members, those members being the heads of government agencies—that is regional managers and CEOs—across the Mid West and Gascoyne regions of Western Australia, and is currently chaired by District Superintendent Andy Greatwood of the WA Police. This group has been in operation since 2006, which is more than eight years. They strive to coordinate resolutions and prioritise locational needs; act as a conduit between community and government departments, systems and processes; and facilitate and clarify funding possibilities to address local issues. The group recently developed a new strategic plan which aims to align the group with the cabinet standing committee on Aboriginal affairs and various state subcommittees. They meet regularly in Geraldton and Carnarvon and have a system of community based subcommittees which collaborate on program delivery, with a good deal of their time dedicated to dealing with the harms of alcohol and drug misuse.

Synthetic psychoactive substances pose a serious risk to the community, just as traditional illicit drugs do. Associated harm and tragic deaths arising from the use of these substances have been well reported. The legislation will ban all psychoactive substances unless they have a legitimate use and will close the loophole that allows people to avoid prosecution by ever so slightly changing the chemical structure of a drug. I commend this bill which amends a series of acts and contains a range of measures to improve Commonwealth criminal justice arrangements, to ban the importation of substances that have a psychoactive effect and that are not otherwise regulated, and to ensure that Australian Customs and Border Protection officers have appropriate powers to stop these substances at the border. I commend this bill to the House.


One step closer to shutting down the synthetic drug trade

Last night the House of Representatives passed the Crimes Legislation Amendment (Psychoactive Substances and Other Measures) Bill 2014.

This legislation will allow law enforcement agencies to charge people who import synthetic drugs whose chemical structures have been deliberately changed so they can be legally imported into our country.

Synthetic drugs are often marketed as legal alternatives to illicit drugs, implying they are somehow safe and credible.

Yet, tragically, we have learned too many times through death or injury to people, especially our young people that this is not the case. These drugs are extremely dangerous.

Existing criminal laws ban illicit drugs based on their chemical structure. However, the rate at which new versions of synthetic drugs appear makes it difficult for our laws to keep up.

These legislative changes put us ahead of the criminals.  Rather than law enforcement agencies having to prove that the particular structure of a psychoactive substance is illegal, all psychoactive substances will be prohibited from importation unless the importer can prove they have a legitimate use.

The new ban will help stop synthetic drugs from being presented as ‘legal’.  Governments and law enforcement agencies will no longer be trying to play catch up every time a ‘new’ synthetic drug is produced.

The ban will add to existing illicit drug offences, which will continue to be the primary way we deal with illicit drugs and the people who try to import them.

The Bill is now subject to debate in the Senate.

Stolen Camper Trailer

Sent in to Everything Geraldton:

"Can you help us? I work for Midwest Men's Health. We have had our display Camper Trailer stolen from our office on Sunday morning at 4:00am. We are a not-for-profit Organisation. Thanks."

Police have been informed. Please contact them if you have any information.  

Thief robs till, returns some, leaves

A Mt Magnet woman will appear in Geraldton Magistrates court after allegedly stealing money from a till at Pure & Divine.  

The incident happened on Friday 14 November. The female entered a small reception area at the rear of the business and walked behind the counter where she opened the cash draw and took $200, according to Police. 

The shop owner saw what had occurred and confronted the offender, who returned $70 and left the shop. 

The 28 year old female will appear before Geraldton Magistrates Court on 4 December 2014. 

AFL player Dayle Garlett charged over stolen car, drug possession

Via ABC:

"Troubled footballer Dayle Garlett is due to face court in Geraldton next month after being arrested for drug possession."

79 year old woman wanted to bite attacker

9News broadcast an interview with the resident of the home where this attack took place, who said the 79 year old victim was disappointed she was unable to get her teeth into him. 

 

"She was upset she couldn't get a bite in. She really wanted to bite him."

Sounds like one feisty 79 year old!

She remarkably received only grazes. 

If you can help identify the attacker in this video please contact Police. 


Posted yesterday:

Your help needed - shocking robbery of 79 year old woman footage captured this morning. 

The robbery occurred at 9:05am Tues, 18th Nov 2014 on Hutchison Street. 

The 79 year old woman was approached by an unidentified male from behind. 

As the footage shows, the woman was pulled to the ground and dragged along as the thief tried to yank the woman's bag from her. 

The video then shows the residents of the home coming to the aid of the victim. 

The offender stole property belonging to the victim and ran off down the path between Hutchison Street and North West Coastal Highway towards Rangeway.

Geraldton Detectives require the public’s assistance in identifying the male offender. 

Please share this and any person with information is asked to please contact Crimestoppers on 1800 333 000 or Geraldton Detectives on (08) 99234555.


$1000 fine for obscuring your number plate

Police are reminding the public that vehicle registration plates must be clearly visible. 

The Road Traffic Regulations enforce how numbers plates are to be fitted to vehicles and section 25AA creates the offence for anything that prevents effective identification of a number plate in varying conditions.

The penalty of which is a fine of $1000.

Click here to view a copy of the regulations.

Video - Shocking robbery of 79 year old woman footage captured this morning in Geraldton

Your help needed - shocking robbery of 79 year old woman footage captured this morning. 

The robbery occurred at 9:05am this morning (Tues, 18th Nov 2014) on Hutchison Street. 

The 79 year old woman was approached by an unidentified male from behind. 

As the footage shows, the woman was pulled to the ground and dragged along as the thief tried to yank the woman's bag from her. 

The video then shows the residents of the home coming to the aid of the victim. 

The offender stole property belonging to the victim and ran off down the path between Hutchison Street and North West Coastal Highway towards Rangeway.

Geraldton Detectives require the public’s assistance in identifying the male offender. 

Please share this and any person with information is asked to please contact Crimestoppers on 1800 333 000 or Geraldton Detectives on (08) 99234555.

People who commit crime are not stupid

Have you ever been at the shops and watched parents fail to control their kids? 

"Get off that now and come." Kid doesn't move. 
"Get off it now or you'll be in trouble." Kid doesn't move.
"You'll be in trouble if you don't come now." Kid doesn't move.
"I'll leave you here if you don't come now." Kid doesn't move. 
"I mean it. You'll be left behind."

You get the idea.

Many of us parents are guilty of this.

We make threats we don't or can't carry out and essentially teach our kids not to believe what we say. We eventually snap and punish the child when we're finally fed up, but really we know it's our own fault for teaching our kids to ignore our instructions.

Yet when it comes to our state's judicial system, we make the exact same mistake. We catch people for committing a crime, give no punishment; catch them again, give no punishment; catch them again, give them a suspended sentence; catch them again, give them a really really strong warning that this is the last time; catch them again, tell them they have exhausted all their chances and they're now off to jail. 

But it's too late to think jail will do much. They have become rather good at stealing and perhaps even dependent on the income it provides. And they genuinely don't know if they'll be in trouble or not each time they're caught. 


Flashback:

I was about 4 or 5 when I stole a packet of gum from the checkout at Coles. 

Mum found out. 

She didn't treat me as though I had stolen a packet of gum. She treated me like I'd stolen a car. I was in SOOOO much trouble

Part of my punishment was the shame of returning to the store and apologising to the staff. I was deeply embarrassed, and had stirred the wrath of my mother like I'd never seen before. 

Guess what; I didn't steal any more. 


At the time I obviously didn't want to be punished. It was painful and it could have been argued no real harm was done in taking a small packet of gum. But my mum was wise enough to know that if she didn't stamp that behaviour out right at the start, I might try stealing other things. 

Now I am grown, I'm extraordinarily grateful that I was punished as a young child and put on a better path. 


Flashback: Criminal neighbours

At 16 I realised I had reached the pinnacle of all wisdom and left home to live with a friend. 

This "friend" unfortunately enjoyed chronic amounts of marijuana.

We also happened to reside a few doors down from some folk who enjoyed drugs and living differently. 

Due to the presence of weed at our place, these delightful neighbours decided to befriend us. There wasn't really much choice on our part as to the depth of the relationship. 

I got to know these individuals and tried and find out what made them tick. Here's a few interesting things that etched themselves into my memory. 

They used to get dressed up and "go to work"

That's what they called it. They would actually decide "today we're going to go and do a bunch of break and enters." They called them B and E's because that sounded cool. They would put on the nicest clothes they had, do their hair, and venture out into the suburbs to see what loot they could find. And they called it going to work. 

They didn't have a job, and they didn't want a job

Each morning I would get up, get dressed and walk to my job at a pet shop where I would clean up animal feces, serve impatient customers, and be on my feet for around 9 hours before walking home, all for about $400 a week.

I distinctly remember my conversation with one of these neighbours who was laughing at my decision to go to work each day.

Me: "Don't you want a job?"

Him: "Why would I want a job? I get money for free!" he said half laughing. "And if I need any more we can do some B & E's."

Me: "Don't you have to look for work in order to get the dole?"

Him: "All you have to do is get the yellow pages and pick some business names and write down their phone numbers."

They knew what to do if they got caught

These guys didn't just rob the odd house on occasion. They had all robbed HUNDREDS AND HUNDREDS of homes. Another of the neighbours shared some tips with me about how to avoid jail.

"Just don't say anything. Deny it. It doesn't matter if the cops catch you, just deny it. They have to prove it and they usually can't. I've got mates who have gone to jail but it's because they talked to the cops."


I was shocked, still am to be honest, that these people were so calculated in their decision to avoid legitimate employment, collect taxpayer funded welfare, and commit as many burglaries as they felt like. 

But it eventually dawned on me. They're not stupid. 


The economics of crime

Economist David D. Friedman has an interesting essay published on the Library of Economics and Liberty.

He asserts that "A mugger is a mugger for the same reason I am an economist—because it is the most attractive alternative available to him. The decision to commit a crime, like any other economic decision, can be analyzed as a choice among alternative combinations of costs and benefits."

In other words, people commit a crime after weighing up the risk vs reward, or the cost vs the benefit. 

They may not open a spreadsheet and run a calculation. 

But, when deciding whether to rob a house or not, the criminal is generally aware of two factors:

A: Roughly how likely it is they will be caught.

B: Roughly what the punishment might be if they are in fact caught. 


Megan McArdle who writes at BloombergView is the author of the book "The Up Side of Down: Why Failing Well is the Key to Success". 

Earlier in the year she was interviewed by well known economist and communicator Russ Roberts, research fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institution. 

Here's a fascinating extract from their conversation:

Roberts: Part of what we are talking about here is responsibility, second chances, moral hazard. All these things tie in to these decisions that we make at the policy level. And it's interesting to me that you profile a parole system that is relentlessly unforgiving, remarkably successful, and actually reduces the problem in an interesting way. So, talk about that briefly. We're low on time, but it's such a great story. 
McArdle: It is a great story. So, it's a judge in Hawaii who looked at the normal parole system. Basically, you've got sort of a suspended prison sentence. And you have to show up for your probation appointments, take regular drug tests, and so forth.
And what happens in a lot of cases is that people violated their parole a bunch of times. And then eventually after 10 or 20 times the probation officer gets fed up and says, Okay, that's it; you are going to prison; you are not complying and we are going to send you.
The judge looked at this, Judge Alm. He said, this is crazy. He said, what we should do is what you do with your kids: every time you violate, we punish you. Instead of nothing, nothing, nothing, nothing, Bam!--5 years in prison.
And so that's what he did: he said, every single time you violate, you are going to jail. But only for a few days. And it has cut the rate of people who end up with prison terms in half.
They save the taxpayer money. And the probationers love it. It's one of the rare kind of win-win.
And I think this actually goes to why bankruptcy is great, and why this works better than traditional probation. Which is, you think about punishment--failure should not, as I say--it should hurt. Which is how you say, Don't do that. But you want it to hurt in a very specific way. And how do you think about that?
First thing, the pain should not be crippling. Right? Second, it should always happen. It should follow from things that don't work. Or in the case of probation often are things that are morally wrong. It happens every time. And then the third thing is that it should enable you to move on. Right?
And that is actually what this is focused on, is keeping you out of jail, keeping you connected to the labor market, to your family, not prisoners where you can learn more about being a criminal.
And it's phenomenally successful at focusing people on the future instead of focusing on their past. Because they are still in the community and they are still learning to be functioning members of the community. So, it's a phenomenally powerful. Because it does hurt. And it hurts immediately.
Over the past 50 years we've been struggling with this crime problem. The answer, though, has been harsher. Three-strikes and you are out laws. Harsher prison sentences. And what Judge Alm said--and what Mark Kleiman, from him I learned about this and who has written a great book on this called When Brute Force Fails--is that this is exactly the wrong way to think about it. (Click here for link to book.)
The thing is not to make the punishment more terrible. It's to make it more consistent.
And it's just remarkably effective.
And I wanted to put this in the book, because I end by talking about forgiveness and how important forgiveness is, and how much cheaper it is than we usually think. We usually spend too much time worrying about abuse and too little time worrying about the people whose lives are affected when we punish them. But that in this case, you do need to punish people.
But then how do you do it so that you maximize the chances of rehabilitation and minimize the damage to both society and the person? And this is why it's such a great story. Because you don't report on a lot of policy stories where there genuinely seem to be very few tradeoffs. But this is one of them.

Click here for full interview.


I found the above conversation fascinating as it asserts that the knee jerk reaction to a crime problem doesn't need to simply be "tougher sentences".

That may be the way to win votes as it appeals to anyone who is a victim of crime, and seems to make sense. But someone has to pay for the prison guards. The taxpayer ends up getting robbed twice, once when his home gets broken into, and again when he has to pay the costs of incarcerating the criminal. 

But there are real world examples of policy makers and enforcers replacing randomised severity with swiftness and certainty of punishment by clearly specifying the rules and then delivering the promised sanctions every time the rules are broken.

And it's working. 


NewsHour Weekend profiles an innovative probation program in Hawaii that has been so successful in reforming offenders and keeping them out of prison, it's now being copied in courtrooms across the nation.

Learn more about Judge Steven Alm and Hawaii's Opportunity Probation with Enforcement (HOPE) program at the below links. 

Video presentation from Judge Alm

Wikipedia entry for HOPE